Segregation Amongst the City

The south side consists of public housing and is generally a lower income area. This is where most of the city’s crime takes place. What stands out is how crime rate is sectioned off by the overpass.











The Most Active Alternatives



Community Grid

dashboard


Consists of demolishing the overpass and replacing it with a boulevard that would encourage more people to visit the city.


Improve conditions for pedestrians and bicyclists. Also would add more activity to the city street grid.


Will most likely cause more traffic on interstate 481; the road that runs east of Syracuse.


Estimated cost: $1.3 billion


"I want to continue to emphasize there's got to be community involvement, particularly people who live in the shadow of 81""

Former Syracuse Mayor Stephanie Miner

Tunnel System

dashboard

Would take 10 years to complete and requires the destruction of 12 buildings


Estimated cost: $4.5 billion


Is not a viable option according to Stephanie Miner but popular alternative according to Governor Andrew Cuomo


No-build

dashboard


Continued routine maintenance and the overpass is not altered


A group called Save i81 believes Interstate 81 allows for easy access for emergency vehicles and specialized health services.


The road also allows for quick accessibility for commuters to travel downtown and students to drive to the university.


This group is openly against the Community Grid alternative






Urban Planning


Unlike engineering or science, planning is not linear. It requires intense public involvement and can comprise of overly optimistic opinions. The process is usually long and consists of analysing the benefits and costs. Planners use their efforts to test the possibility of a project and do not think like scientists or engineers.

Wicked Problems


In planning there is a term used called wicked problems created by Melvin Webber & Horst Rittel. The term is described as a problem that cannot be solved but resolved by a collective agreement.


Some Principles Include

  • 1. There is no definitive formulation of a Wicked Problem
  • 2. Wicked Problems have no stopping rule
  • 3. Solutions to Wicked Problems are not true-or-false, but good-or-bad
  • 4. There is no immediate and no ultimate test of a solution to a Wicked Problem
  • 5. Every wicked problem can be considered to be a symptom of another problem

Transportation systems in the past such as the Erie canal and Railways have caused Syracuse to thrive.

It was not until the interstate highway system did we start to see devastation throughout communities.

To combat problems like these, planners need to be cautious of the conclusion they make because it will impact the way we live.

Thesis Project by Joseph Stella


To lean more about Syracuse's overpass problem please visit